Friday, January 16, 2015

But I can't afford brand new, so why look at dealers?

Oh no! A winter night transmission crap out sounds about zero fun. 
Now you're in the market but aren't looking to buy brand new. Maybe just 2010-2013. And your trade-in probably isn't worth much.

Looking at used car lots is one route for sure, but also remember, dealers take back leased cars of their own brands. Most leases are 36 months so that puts you right in your year range. It also means decent mileage because leases have mileage limits. Plus, since maintenance is often included in a lease, folks are more likely to actually have the car serviced regularly.
Also, places like CarSense carry cars of all makes and models but under strict quality standards. They have no haggle pricing but that doesn't mean you can't haggle your trade in value.

I still recommend a couple visits and test drives. There are plenty of fish in the sea, so to speak. Letting one dealer determine what you will drive for possibly the next 5-10 years isn't necessary, even with a budget to stick to.

As for figuring your trade in you - call a few mechanics and ask for a ballpark price to replace the transmission. Assume it would cost a car dealer half that. KBB minus half the transmission cost is probably a good trade in value goal.
Unless of course that puts you less than half the $3600 you have in mind. In that case, you will want to arbitrarily decide on say, $2,000. They have that much built into their pricing profits anyway, and most aren't willing to lose a sale on a few dollars. Which reminds me, moving inventory ("floor space") is very important to new car dealers. They get their allowances, their dealer holdbacks and their pick of hot selling models from the manufacturers based on the numbers they move. The actual profit per sale is just icing on the cake. Service is where dealers make like 80% of their profits. And for them, even moving a used car frees up floor space.

Now onto an even cheaper car - Say your budget is under 10k. 
A high volume dealer (like Gary Barbera, though I can't stand them) will get all sorts of trade ins. They usually just pass them off to an auctioneer or some other third party but on a good week, may have anything laying around from an old neon to a Cadillac. Just the nature of cars. 
But if instead you end up at a traditional used car dealer for his car, ask if they offer a warranty. My dad's little rule was that if they are willing to offer it (for a moderate price point), that's good enough. No need to actually buy it unless you're interested in this kind of thing. Of course that advice was for cars in the $2,000 price range, I just think it sounds pretty solid for any used car.

I did a spreadsheet for the a previous purchase which is absolute GOLD! I will see if I can load it onto this blog.
You definitely want to play around with that so you'll know what bottom line price point you can afford in order to get to your desired monthly payment before you even walk into a dealer.

For example, if you can get Subaru to agree to $18,000k for This 2013 Forrester, with 2,000 down and a 2,000 trade in value - your payments would probably be under $270. It's got less than 35,000 miles on it. Which reminds me, "certified used" isn't an official terminology. A crappy used car lot under the El can use that term to mean they will certify that it is, in fact used. (only half joking.) A particular brand, say, BWM on the other hand, may develop a very specific inspection/replacement protocol in order to designate cars as "certified." Maybe if you have time and you narrow your search to a few brands, find out what their version of "certified used" means.

This Rav-4 may be a few bucks above your ideal but if you can find a credit union to get you a 5 year loan for 4% and get your trade in to be worth $6,000  - you're looking at a payment around $350. Toyota practically invented high quality. (Literally, a dude named Taichi Ohno.)

Like I said, I'll check to see if I can upload the spreadsheet. It was all fancy and interactive.

Buying a car - basic advice

So you're in the market for a car.

Imagine Bob the Sales guy at Brand X is great and treats customers well. You go there, and you buy X's small SUV. But what if Brand Y's small SUV is a better fit for you? No fault of Bob's, he just only sells X. That's why I highly recommend driving at least three distinct brands' offerings, Then ask folks for recommendations on dealers or sales folks for the brand you choose. Hyundai, for example. I can think of three different dealers within relative proximity.

Also, you should have absolutely no fear about walking right into a dealership and saying "I want to drive the Rav-4." Drive it, take the sales person's card, then peace out and on to the next. I've literally gone to both a Range Rover and BMW dealership and said I wanted to drive their $60k Crossover because I was thinking of maybe getting a Crossover next time.

 Too many people cower because the traditional car buying model in this country sucks and get roped into being sold something they don't truly want. Sometimes you can find several brands with dealers right near each other. The Airport Auto Mall is a great example. The Pacifico group has Ford, Mazda and Hyundai all in a row.

And if SUVs don't tickle your fancy this time around, don't count out Subaru. All but one of their cars (it's practically a go-kart and I test drove it three times) comes with AWD and they have a great reputation of lasting forever. A lot of their sedans and hatchbacks have been restyled in the past few years and are quite sharp.

As for your buying experience in general, you'll also want to know the value of your trade in and bring a spreadsheet of payments per various interest rates. I've done this to prove dealers are shady. My husband traded in 2004 2-door Wrangler for a 2011 4-door and I shit you not, when they made us the first "offer", the monthly payment was like $450. I had a spreadsheet with me which basically meant at the 0% interest they were offering, they were either charging us thousands OVER sticker price or were only giving us $2k for the trade in. By the time we walked away, the trade in was $11,000 and the payment was $333. They focus on that monthly payment because that's how most of us budget but if you aren't prepared with the math, they can sneak in major cash for no reason. Plus in PA, the value of your trade in is deducted from the cost of the car to calculate sales tax so its to your benefit to negotiate for a higher trade in value as compared to a lower sales price. 8% is no joke.